Random Crit is kind of frustrating when it comes at bad times. But it's all fair.

Turning off random crit will cause balancing problems as some weapons have "no random crits" as their drawbacks. Think about how OP eyelander/southern hospitailty etc. would be without random crit.

So I would say, keep it. Play match if it is too much of a problem for you.

not that my word makes a difference, but i would prefer no random crits if i could choose. Its not skill or anything to kill people by it, and no matter how good you are, you cant avoid it. But thats just my opinionn :)

Could we get an option to vote for it in the beginning of a match?

This plugin is 3 years old and the last post stated that it no longer work with newer versions of TF2 ...

If you want to play games of pure skill competition I would suggest you organize some scrims (or more casual than scrim) games with other interested players. HSP.HK provides 2 servers specifically for such purpose. Valve stated many times "nocrit" servers are not part of "normal" TF2 games, and nocrit servers will not be listed in quick-play capable server list, 50% of casual TF2 players will be isolated from such servers. Currently HSP.HK cannot afford to provide more servers for small player groups of specific interest, but we can promise our players if the proposed co-operation with GamersUnited can be actualized, we will provide servers like "nocrit", or modded games like jump, trade, saxton hale, etc.

Personally, I dislike random crits mainly due to how random it is (well it's called random for a reason, you bloody idiot). How I think is like this: To a skilled player, killing someone with a random crit gives no satisfaction, just an 'oh, luck was on my side, I did not deserve that kill'; and to a non-skilled player, managing to kill someone due to luck would not make him try to improve his play.

Also because I'm tired of only getting crits when rocket jumping, damnit.

And to the argument that some weapons with 'no random crits' are overpowered in that setting: it'll be the same as any other melee, pretty much. And they have other downsides too, remember? Skullcutter will still be on par with Eyelander for continuous damage; an Engineer will probably still kill a spy with 1 more swing anyway; the Claidheamh Mòr... wait why am I even talking about that, literally no one uses that anyway.

On the flipside, that one day when Valve experimented with giving no random crit melees random crits and -25% damage... didn't really work out that well either. Critting with Eyelander all day e'ery day.